ALL IN Charters
Key West, Florida
5950 Peninsular Ave, Key West, Florida, 33040
Welcome to ALL IN Charters, where Captain Garrett Frey invites you to embark on a fishing adventure of a lifetime.
With over 14 years of experience specializing in bottom fishing for Snappers, Groupers, Sharks, and some many other species. Captain Frey guarantees a unique and unforgettable experience on each trip by offering a (No Fish No Pay) guarantee. Captain Frey’s focus on bottom fishing ensures consistent action and a hands-on experience for all anglers.
“ALL IN” accommodates up to 6 passengers aboard a 29′ SeaVee center console.
Whether you’re a seasoned angler or a first-timer, all ages are welcome.
With you in full control, holding the rod, feeling the bite, and hooking your own fish, your charter with ALL IN is sure to deliver great action!
Book today and join Captain Garrett Frey for an unparalleled and unforgettable fishing adventure!
×
Book Now
Guests
Book Your Trip
Half Day: Fishing Charter (Nearshore)
$900.00 USD
Starts at: 08:00 AM
Duration: 4 hours
Come join us for a half day of fishing!
Deep water wreck and reef fishing is the most popular charter that Captain Garrett typically runs. Our usual approach involves anchoring near a shipwreck or drifting over it with live bait.
The deep wrecks, often within 15 miles from the dock, offer a fantastic option for a family-friendly adventure. Join us for a shorter trip packed with excitement for everyone!
Book Now3/4 Day: Fishing Charter (Nearshore/Offshore)
$1100.00 USD
Starts at: 08:00 AM
Duration: 6 hours
Our 3/4 day trip gives you a great opportunity to target a wide variety of species!
On this charter our typical approach includes anchoring near a shipwreck or drifting over it with live bait. The deep wrecks, are conveniently located within 15 miles from the dock.
Secure your spot today for the perfectly happy medium!
Book NowFull Day - Fishing Charter (Nearshore/Offshore)
$1500.00 USD
Starts at: 08:00 AM
Duration: 8 hours
If you’re aiming to fill up the cooler and enjoy a full day packed with thrilling fights, this is the perfect trip for you!
With the entire day at our disposal, we can explore the reefs and wrecks, troll offshore, and much more. Opting for a full day ensures the best opportunity to target a variety of fish species!
Book Now3 Hours - Shark Fishing
$700.00 USD
Starts at: 07:30 AM
Duration: 3 hours
Flat calm waters and lots of action!
Inshore shark fishing aboard the all-in is a relaxing and at the same time exciting way to spend a morning or an afternoon on the water.
Three hours shark trips are typically from 7:30am to 10:30am or in the evening from 5:00pm to 8:00pm.
Book NowHalf Day - Shark Charter
$900.00 USD
Starts at: 08:00 AM
Duration: 4 hours
Key West is home to some of the best and most diverse shark fishing in the world. With such a vast area of reef and tons of wrecks, the sharks are always lurking.
We see bull sharks, hammerheads, lemons, tigers, sandbar, caribbean reef, and even from time to time we see mako sharks. We often see and land fish well over 200lbs.
Shark fishing is by far one of my favorite trips I personally offer. Most sharks are just catch and release but some can make great table fare or that once in a lifetime trophy.
Book Now3/4 Day - Shark Charter
$1100.00 USD
Starts at: 08:00 AM
Duration: 6 hours
Key West is home to some of the best and most diverse shark fishing in the world!
With such a vast area of reef and tons of wrecks, the sharks are always lurking. We see bull sharks, hammerheads, lemons, tigers, sandbar, caribbean reef, and even from time to time we see mako sharks. We often see and land fish well over 200lbs.
Shark fishing is by far one of my favorite trips I personally offer. Most sharks are just catch and release but some can make great table fare or that once in a lifetime trophy.
Book NowTrip Features:
Cleaning & Filleting
Upon arrival from your day on the water, your catch will be filleted and bagged for you and your family/friends to take home and enjoy!
Live Bait Well
Our Captain’s boat is equipped with a live bait well, which may be used to hold bait and other smaller fish you may catch.
Rods, Reels, & Tackle
Our Captains are prepared with all the equipment necessary to catch whatever may swim your way! All the rods, reels, tackle, and bait will be provided to target whatever species you are hoping to catch!
You Keep Catch
Aside from the species required to be released by law and some species that may not be recommended as table fair, whatever fish are landed while out on the water are yours to keep!
What To Bring:
Additional Drinks
Camera
Cash
Hat
Non-Spray Sunscreen
Small Cooler
Snacks/Food
Sunglasses
Weather-Appropriate Clothing
Boat Specs:
29' SeaVee | Center Console- Length: 29'
- Capacity: 6 Persons
- Hull: SeaVee
- Built: 2005
Types of Fish:
- African Pompano
- Amberjack (Greater)
- Barracuda
- Bonito (Atlantic)
- Cobia
- Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
- Grouper (Black)
- Grouper (Goliath)
- Grouper (Nassau)
- Grouper (Red)
- Grouper (Rock Hind)
- Grouper (Scamp)
- Grouper (Snowy)
- Grouper (Warsaw)
- Grouper (Yellowedge)
- Grouper (Yellowfin)
- Grouper (Yellowmouth)
- Herring
- Jack (Almaco)
- Jack (Crevalle)
- Jack (Horse-Eye)
- Lobster
- Mackerel (Atlantic)
- Mackerel (Cero)
- Mackerel (King)
- Mackerel (Spanish)
- Margate
- Marlin (Blue)
- Marlin (White)
- Permit
- Porgy
- Rainbow Runner
- Red Snapper
- Sailfish
- Shark
- Snapper (Blackfin)
- Snapper (Cubera)
- Snapper (Dog)
- Snapper (Lane)
- Snapper (Mangrove)
- Snapper (Mutton)
- Snapper (Red)
- Snapper (Schoolmaster)
- Snapper (Vermilion)
- Snapper (Yellowtail)
- Swordfish
- Tarpon
- Tilefish (Blue)
- Tilefish (Golden)
- Triggerfish (Gray)
- Triggerfish (Ocean)
- Tripletail
- Tuna (Albacore)
- Tuna (Blackfin)
- Wahoo
Listing Policies:
- Child Friendly
- Cooler
- Fish Processing
Boat Reviews:
Daniel Rodney
By far the best fishing charter in Key West. Garrett knows the waters and is an absolutely fantastic guide. Although I got seasick at one point, it was still a sweet day full of great memories.
Rating:
5
Paul Teichert
Although Captain Garrett wasn’t the cheapest charter in key west, he was honest all along about what we could expect to catch. It is clear that Capt. Garrett loves what he does. He is very knowledgable and put us on the fish almost right away. This was the best fishing in Key West that I’ve done to date.
Rating:
5
Jackie Fischer
My husband and I were looking for a local charter in Key West who was reputable. We heard about Capt. Garrett through a friend and ended up booking with him. We were not disappointed! We caught live bait and ended up hooking several amberjacks, mahi-mahi, and grouper + tilefish. Deep dropping was such a cool experience that me and my husband both appreciated. We’ve never seen fish like that before! Thank you, Capt. Garrett for a wonderful day, we recommend anybody looking to book a fishing charter in Key West to book with him.
Rating:
5
Andy Harmon
Garrett is the man! He works incredibly hard and always puts us on the fish. Second time fishing with him in the last year. 😏
Rating:
5
Kathryn Norman
Captain Garrett is hilarious and very knowledgeable. This was one of the best days we had together as a family. We will definitely be rebooking with Capt. Garrett. next time we are in Key West visiting. When we got back to the dock he filleted the fish for us and encourage us to go to a restaurant down the street to have it cooked. Highlight of the year!
Rating:
5
Bob Kenyon
Awesome day! We caught nine mutton, three nurse sharks, a Margate, four snappers, and a bunch of kingfish.
Rating:
5
Nick Silva
My friends and I booked a four hour trip with Capt. Garrett. He took us to fish the reefs and wrecks in Key West. Despite it being a slightly rougher day, it didn’t stop Garrett from making us feel safe and comfortable. We ended up having a great time regardless of the conditions. If you’re looking for a fishing charter in Key West, I highly recommend Booking with "All In".
Rating:
5
JD King
Capt Garrett was awesome! We had a great time catching a variety of fish during our 3/4 day trip. Fish were consistently being reeled in throughout the day. We would definitely book go again without hesitation!
Rating:
5
Justin Keller
Had an excellent time fishing with Captain Garrett. Planning to book again next year when I visit Key West! Highly recommend!
Rating:
5
Kristen Graham
Fishing with Captain Garrett has been consistently fantastic! We've gone out with him three times and are continually impressed by his expertise and understanding of fishing. He's especially good with kids and has a way of finding the fish. We're eagerly anticipating our next fishing trip with All In!
Rating:
5
Eddy Weisger
What a day! Despite Key West experiencing two months of no rain, our scheduled charter day turned out to be a downpour (of course). It was honestly a miserable day weather-wise. However, our captain didn't cancel on us. Instead, he worked tirelessly, ensuring we had a great fishing trip despite the conditions. If he can turn a rainy day into a fun fishing adventure, I can only imagine how enjoyable it would be on a beautiful day. This captain is your go-to guy for an unforgettable fishing experience in the Florida Keys!
Rating:
5
Caleb Salvemini
Captain Garrett was amazing! We went on a half-day fishing trip, and he made sure that we had a successful day and fish to take home. I highly recommend him if your looking to fish in key west! We particularly enjoyed his Harry Potter references 🤣 I highly recommend him.
Rating:
5
Linda Sienkiewicz
Our experience with Captain Garrett was 10/10! He's not only highly knowledgeable but also knows the best fishing spots. Despite our limited expertise, he was energetic and patient with us. We caught African Pompanos, grouper, and a shark during our fishing charter. It was an exciting day, and I would highly recommend Garrett to anyone looking for a great fishing experience in Key West.
Rating:
5
Rick Buck
We had an amazing time fishing with All IN Fishing Charters. During our four-hour trip, we caught tuna and about 10 sharks (haha). Captain Garrett was fantastic — patient, informative, and made the whole experience enjoyable. I highly recommend this fishing charter to anyone seeking a fantastic day on the water in Key West. We'll definitely be returning!
Rating:
5
Jake Lambert
Had a great time fishing w/ Capt. Garrett in Key West. We caught Amberjack, Barracuda, and more. Garrett was a great captain and knew where to find the biggest and best fish! Highly recommend this fishing charter if you want to fish in the Keys.
Rating:
5
Braden Belmas
Captain Garret is exceptional! He'll get you on the fish and hooked up in no time. Garrett is professional and will ensure you'll have a fantastic time. His knowledge of the waters is unmatched and he wastes no time. I'd rate the trip an 11 out of 10 because he's just that good! This charter experience is the real deal, thanks to Captain Garret's expertise.
Rating:
5
x
SUBSCRIBE NOW
FOR A CHANCE TO WIN FREE FISHING CHARTERS, REEL GUIDES MERCH, AND MORE!